Accused of Violating a New York Order of Protection? Take It Seriously.

Accused of Violating a New York Order of Protection? Take It Seriously.

One text. One phone call about the kids. One visit to pick up your belongings. If an order of protection prohibits that contact, something you thought was harmless can become a new criminal case.

What Is an Order of Protection in New York?

An order of protection directs someone to stay away from another person or refrain from specified conduct. New York courts issue these orders in criminal cases, Family Court proceedings, and divorce actions. Temporary orders are enforceable even though they are not findings that you committed a crime.

A full stay-away order generally prohibits approaching the protected person or designated locations and may bar calls, texts, social media messages, and contact through others. A friendly message or a call about the kids can still violate it. Follow any court-authorized exceptions exactly.

A limited or refrain-from order prohibits specified conduct, such as threats, assault, or harassment, without necessarily banning all contact. The written terms—not the label—control. If multiple orders apply, you must comply with each.

Need belongings from your home or a workable child-exchange arrangement? Have your lawyer seek court authorization for an “access order”. Paying rent or having your name on the lease does not override a stay-away provision.

Online activity and unexpected encounters require context. A tag or comment may constitute prohibited communication; an accidental encounter is not the same as deliberate contact. If you unexpectedly see the protected person, leave safely rather than starting a conversation.

Criminal Contempt in the Second Degree: Penal Law § 215.50(3)

Under Penal Law § 215.50(3), the prosecution must prove a lawful order, your knowledge of its relevant terms, and intentional disobedience beyond a reasonable doubt. If contact itself was prohibited, prosecutors need not prove you intended to frighten or hurt anyone.

This Class A misdemeanor carries up to 364 days in jail under Penal Law § 70.15(1). Probation, a conditional discharge, or a fine may also be available. Jail is not automatic.

Criminal Contempt in the First Degree: Penal Law § 215.51

Certain threatening or harassing conduct, intentional property damage, or qualifying prior contempt convictions can support this Class E felony. The prosecution must prove the specific requirements of the subsection charged—not simply unwanted contact or the existence of an old case.

Under Penal Law § 70.00, the potential maximum prison term is four years. The actual sentencing options depend on the case and your record.

Aggravated Criminal Contempt: Penal Law § 215.52

This Class D felony includes intentionally or recklessly causing physical injury or serious physical injury to the protected person while violating the order, as well as certain repeat-offender circumstances. Physical injury means impairment of physical condition or substantial pain under Penal Law § 10.00(9); mere contact does not automatically qualify.

The potential maximum prison term is seven years under Penal Law § 70.00.

How Do You Defend an Order-of-Protection Violation Charge?

Hire a Criminal Defense attorney to inspect  the actual order, its effective dates, and any modifications. What did it prohibit? Did you know its terms? Was the alleged violation intentional? The answers matter more than someone’s description of what happened.

Lack of formal personal service is not an automatic defense: prosecutors may establish actual knowledge through other evidence. Your defense must address what you knew.

Then test the evidence. Was the message yours? Is the screenshot complete? Do phone records, witnesses, or video contradict the accusation? A complaint is not the whole story, and unsupported allegations deserve a serious challenge. The Law Offices of Jason Krinsky regularly defends Client’s alleged to have violated Order of Protections.

“They Contacted Me First” Does Not Change the Order

The protected person cannot privately cancel a court order. An invitation to come over, a request to call, or a promise not to involve the police does not authorize conduct the order prohibits. Only the court can modify or terminate the order. The police and prosecutor’s office can charge you for violating an order of protection regardless of whether that protected party consented to such contact. The only way to have future lawful conduct is to have the order of protection removed.

Receiving messages from a protected party? Preserve incoming messages, but under no circumstances should you reply. Should you wish to have communication in the future your lawyer should seek any necessary change from the court before so.

What Should You Do Now?

Take the whole situation seriously. Beyond jail, a felony or misdemeanor conviction, a contempt case may affect release conditions, probation or parole, employment, immigration status, firearm possession, and custody disputes. Consequences depend on the facts and disposition.

If police contact you, invoke your rights to counsel and your right to remain silent, hire a good private attorney like the Law Offices of Jason Krinsky as soon as possible. Always have a good attorney on speed dial. Your future could depend on it.

Talk to Jason Krinsky Before You Make Your Next Move

At the Law Offices of Jason Krinsky, we build your defense around the order, the evidence, and the law. We challenge unsupported allegations and fight for your freedom and future. Do not wait for your next court date to mount your defense. The prosecutor is already building their case. You should hire an attorney to do the same.

Call Jason H. Krinsky, Esq., at 917-991-8006 for a free consultation. You can also email hamiltonkrinskylaw@gmail.com. The Law Offices of Jason Krinsky serves the five boroughs, New Jersey and Connecticut.  

We fight for you.

This article provides general information about New York law and is not legal advice for a particular case. Contacting the firm does not, by itself, create an attorney-client relationship.

Available 24 / 7

Call now to be directly connected with Criminal Defense Attorney Jason Krinsky.

Avvo Clients' Choice 2025